Holidays, Hugs, and Hope
Hope Springs Eternal
Spring is springing, buds are budding, and crocuses are croaking. The vaccination is about to let many of us off the lead and unleash a deluge of pent-up demand for travel, eating out, and reconnecting with family and friends. So, in what I hope might be the last in this series of crystal ball blogs trying to find a chink of light at the end of a seemingly interminable tunnel of semi-incarceration, here is a bunch of ‘S’es for spring: a bouquet of observations with a scent of hope.
A ‘mantra for the moment’ follows each main ‘S’ trend below. These one-liners attempt to summarise what travellers are thinking and how businesses might address their needs.
‘S’ is for SPRING
Spring Follows Winter
According to Andy Haldane, Chief Economist at the Bank of England, “the UK economy is like a coiled spring, ready to release large amounts of pent-up financial energy”.
This is not to suggest spring will be a bed of roses. It won’t. More of a wild garden with some green shoots, a few flowers blooming, and some barren patches left over from an economic winter.
And it’s been a grim winter. The global travel and tourism sector suffered a loss of almost $4.5 trillion last year, with more than 62 million jobs lost, and international travel spending down 69.4% on 2019 levels, according to the World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC). Visit Britain estimates the damage to inbound tourism to the UK in 2020 amounted to a drop of 76% in visits to 9.7 million, and 80% in spending to £5.7 billion.
The post-pandemic travel canvas will be a picture in two parts: part monochrome and part colour. While many have suffered, and many jobs and businesses may not come back, many jobs will return, businesses will reopen, and people will travel.
The big unknown is just how many. How many businesses will survive to reopen? How many of the c.5 million people currently furloughed will return to jobs, after the Chancellor ends the Job Retention Scheme in September and hard choices need to be made about business viability? Where will it be possible to travel, and when?
Deliberate Plans to Spend Accidental Savings
Despite the devastating economic impact and inequalities that have been exacerbated by COVID-19, there will be people in work, retired, and with cash to spend from ‘accidental’ savings during lockdown. Having saved on commuting, childcare, eating out, travel, and other indulgences, travel will be the single biggest beneficiary of spending after we come out of lockdown, according to research by the Trajectory Partnership.
Characterised, somewhat distastefully, by some as ‘revenge travel’, we are likely to see a surge in travel, as soon as permissible, particularly to familiar and easily accessible places. And recovery is likely to be faster than after the 2008 recession, because the economic infrastructure has not been universally ravaged to the extent it was in 2008. Despite some significant damage, the economy in 2021 is probably more dormant than dead, and therefore more coiled to spring back than it was in 2008. At least that’s the hope.
Turning the Corner
VisitBritain is forecasting a modest growth in inbound visits this year of 21% over 2020, which still takes them to only 29% of the 2019 level; and 16% growth in spend over 2020, which represents only 23% of the 2019 level. Nevertheless, it’s an indication the corner will be turned and the journey to recovery is about to start.
The third wave of infections around the world and variable vaccination rates, especially in major European destinations, probably mean the summer will happen mainly at home. Short-haul international travel may pick up as vaccinations kick in, but probably not before late autumn. And long-haul is unlikely to show significant vital signs until 2022. Airlines are looking to 2025 as the year passenger traffic might return to 2019 levels.
Mantra for the moment: “After rain comes sunshine”.
‘S’ is for STAYCATION
No Room at the Inn
The star of the tourism firmament in between lockdowns in 2020, domestic holidays will again prove the most resilient sector in 2021.
Try booking a half-decent self-catering cottage or an AirBnB anywhere in Britain for the rest of the year and you’ll spend a long time searching. Bookings have been flooding in since the UK government’s ‘data not dates’ announcement outlined a list of dates for gradually letting us off the lead. Interestingly, recent research into Scots’ tourism intentions by 56 Degree Insight showed a swing of +25% in favour of self-catering, perhaps indicating the value people attach to both independence and safety in forthcoming holidays.
As well as short-term rentals, this has to be good for restaurants, food providers, cafes, and pubs, as well as, hopefully, visitor attractions, activity operators, and all manner of visitor experiences, which can cater to domestic travellers, as long as they can open up and infections are suppressed. People travel to do more than sleep in someone else's bed.
Autumn Threat
The big concern is a third wave may result from people returning from foreign holidays, who travel overseas as soon as the ban on international travel is lifted, resulting in a further lockdown in late autumn. This would be a blow for all those holidaymakers and businesses anticipating staycations in the autumn. Fingers crossed there will be sufficient vaccination coverage and effective testing by then to keep this under control.
Repeat Visitors
Many people will have experienced the delights of their own country for the first time in 2020 and 2021. The more they enjoy the experience and the more they are exposed to the diversity of things to do, places to see, good food, and great fun, the greater the chance they will repeat their visit in future years and become ambassadors for their own land: less ‘stay home-stay safe’ and more ‘open your eyes-stay home’, at least for one or more breaks a year.
Mantra for the moment: “Give people a good time today and they’ll come back tomorrow”.
‘S’ is for SPACE
Room to Breathe
Outdoors is the new ‘cool’. After getting a taste for the delights of the countryside, partly from a craving for space to enable comfortable social distancing and partly from a concern to escape the type of crowds cities make it hard to avoid, will people return to shopping malls when they can? Probably not in pre-pandemic numbers.
Space, as represented by scenic rural areas, will become much more sought after. Rural destinations will boom. This brings with it the need for places to manage a level of growth they are not equipped to do. Problems of ‘overtourism’ more familiar to Venice and Barcelona may begin to afflict local beauty spots at the expense of their beauty.
Local authorities need to use the lockdown calm before the visitor invasion storm to think about a wide range of visitor management issues, from traffic flow, access, and parking, to toilets and litter – all issues we saw cause congestion, disruption, and detritus last year. They may hope for the best, but they need to plan for the worst.
Mantra for the moment: “Planning needs to start now to save places from themselves”.
‘S’ is for SLOW
Tune In , Slow Down
Slow is the new synonym for engagement and empathy. Having discovered space in rural destinations, it seems likely people will tune into these places, slow their pace of exploration, and seek fulfilment in local experiences, from regional cuisine to local traditions and culture, which make the place what it is, and spend longer in it.
This offers an opportunity for places to keep people longer by offering insights into their character and encouraging visitors to look beyond the brochure, under stones, and anywhere that might reveal intriguing stories about the place. Think ‘destination as living museum’ and ‘place of engagement’ – cultural immersion rather than passive sightseeing.
Mantra for the moment: “Find a way to be part of it”.
‘S’ is for SAFETY
Stay Safe by Being Informed
Safety has been elevated beyond a ‘hygiene factor’ in the holiday decision-making process to a ‘must-have’.
Safety will remain a concern for months to come. Travellers will want to know their intended destination, means of transport, accommodation, and places they might visit, all take visitor safety seriously. While hygiene and safety measures may not be a competitive advantage, they will almost certainly be a competitive disadvantage if places don’t apply them assiduously and communicate this effectively to potential visitors.
This means hygiene and safety measures will need to be included up-front in their marketing communications by tourism businesses in a way they never have been before.
Concern for safety has become deeply embedded in consumer consciousness. Businesses should recognise that failing to mention their safety precautions is like failing to mention they have wi-fi: if it’s not mentioned, that must be because it doesn’t exist.
The emphasis on safety, as suggested by the popularity of self-catering, seems to be reinforced by further evidence from 56 Degree Insight’s recent findings that Scottish holidaymakers say they’re more likely now to buy takeaways (+15%) and food to cook in their holiday home (+31%) than in pre-pandemic days……….But probably more Hairy Bikers than KFC.
This might also spur a growth in pop-up restaurants and outdoor eating places in towns and cities. ‘Culinary concept spaces’ are becoming ‘cool’ as well as spaced, from the Seafood Shack in Ullapool to Cargo in Bristol and Freight Island in Manchester. But even they will need to convey their safety credentials.
Mantra for the moment: “When it comes to safety, absence of evidence is evidence of absence”.
‘S’ is for SPLURGE
Paying a Premium
Partly as a result of pent-up demand and partly ‘accidental savings’, many people will be willing to spend more on their holidays. They may have to, as the pressure of demand, particularly for scarcer accommodation, pushes prices up.
Tour operators are reporting a greater willingness amongst customers to pay for upgrades, particularly for accommodation, and to buy more add-ons to ensure they get the best slot, sea view, or just guaranteed access to an iconic attraction. You don’t want to spend a fortune on travelling half the length of the country only to find Stonehenge is fully booked or there’s no space on the dolphin-watching boat until the week after you leave.
This is likely to stretch to splurging on better quality accommodation, more gastronomic experiences, finer wines, and unusual experiences. Whether this will continue as a sustained trend, or merely reflects a celebration of emergence from domestic incarceration, remains to be seen. But the first wave of post-lockdown travel is likely to be characterised by a certain degree of indulgence.
Mantra for the moment: “A lavish reward for coping with a year of abstinence”.
‘S’ is for SIBLINGS
Happy Families
Well, not just siblings – the whole family. Global crises have an effect of bringing families together. For many, who haven’t seen their parents, children, grandchildren, and other family members for the best part of a year, the desire to get together will be powerful. This is likely to translate into multi-generational family holidays, just to see each other again. Missed Christmas gatherings will be re-enacted all over the country.
We saw a growth in family and multi-generational holidays after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the USA. A combination of shock and sadness at the number of lives lost, which brings the fragility of existence dramatically home, plus such a long stretch without seeing each other, will surely fuel this desire to get together in places beyond the home.
Larger rental properties, particularly in rural areas, which can accommodate family groups, stand to benefit from this. It also means restaurants may need to be prepared to accommodate larger party sizes with bigger tables and flexible dining configurations. The family that stays together eats together.
Mantra for the moment: “Think big, be flexible”.
‘S’ is for SOCIAL
Well, not just social media, but all manner of apps and an accelerating adoption of increasingly clever technology. Drivers behind this trend will be:
- Concern for safety: No-one wants to touch anything. This will manifest itself in increasingly contactless and cashless transactions and personally accessible information, from hotel check-in and checkout, transport tickets, and retail purchases, to food-ordering, automatic doors, and all manner of information. People will increasingly expect this all to be accessible on the move 24/7– via mobile platforms, with no business or institutional hurdle between them and the service.
Mantra for the moment: “Look, no hands”.
- Currency and relevance: Big brother-style big data enables quite precise insights into people’s preferences, locations, and behaviour. People will expect all information to be bang up to date, personally relevant, and local. This will be a two-way process. Visitors might search for places to eat nearby that have availability in an hour. But a vegan restaurant might also push its availability to any vegans within a 1-hour radius. The opportunities for clever destination management and filling trough periods for businesses are extensive.
Mantra for the moment: “Real, relevant, and right now”.
- Fear of missing out (FOMO): No-one wants to miss out on holiday fun. The anticipated boom in domestic travel and probable ongoing need for social distancing are likely to increase visitor pressure on certain places and certain businesses at certain times. On the one hand, this is likely to encourage advance booking, to be sure of not missing out. On the other, clever apps should provide information on busy and quieter times to empower visitors to make informed choices about where to go when. This will reduce frustration and queuing and help visitors have a more fulfilling holiday by removing uncertainty and giving them some of their time back.
Mantra for the moment: “My time, my choice”.
- The way of the world: The world is wired. For all these reasons, and because the younger you are the more you expect to have the world at your fingertips, technological solutions to every material desire will be expected. That’s just the way of the world. If you can’t find the information you want, book where you want to go, arrange deliveries, pay for them, and communicate with the people you want, from your mobile phone, they won’t exist, at least in the millennial and Gen Z consciousness.
Just as Charles Darwin could never have imagined space travel, expect advances we can’t even dream of today, which will make life easier, everything more do-able, and place control in our hands. The rate of technological change has always been exponential. The pandemic has accelerated this, as we’ve found ways to overcome enforced physical remoteness through virtual means of communication, working, service delivery, entertainment, and education.
Technology will shrink space and shorten time. And it will do all this from the phone in your pocket.
Mantra for the moment: “If it’s not in my pocket, it doesn’t exist”.
THREE BIG QUESTIONS ABOUT THE FUTURE
Will These Trends Continue?
Are these current trends just flashes in the pan, a reaction to months of lockdown, which will dissipate after people have drunk from the Pierian spring of ‘revenge travel’?
Will we continue to find pleasure in small things, pass by more slowly, and soak up the atmosphere of places? Or will we revert to our more frenetic, pre-pandemic, patterns of consumptive behaviour, in which the default is a desire to be entertained rather than entertain ourselves? And will the associated concern for our impact on the environment and local communities last only as long as no-frills airlines remain grounded?
The answer, as ever, is likely to be a mix of all of the above. But the question is, how far will the pendulum swing back, and how many people will change their behaviour on a permanent basis?
Maybe, just maybe, we might see a shift in values towards more sustainable travel behaviour, particularly amongst younger travellers. The Greta Thunberg snowball that started an avalanche of socially responsible travel amongst more people than even she dared hope may gather momentum.
But one thing we can be sure of is technological innovation will continue to make things easier and contactless. The dark ages of cumbersome physical steps to book, check-in, make purchases, and obtain services, are behind us.
Will We Face a Third Wave Lockdown?
Amid the euphoria engendered by the prospect of mass vaccination in some countries, lies a concern over limited access to vaccination in others. Variable vaccination rates worldwide will delay suppression of the virus in unvaccinated populations. It will also heighten the risk of mutation and new, vaccine-proof strains emerging.
This raises the issue of travellers returning home with new variants to initiate a new cycle of infection, which would almost certainly result in the imposition of further lockdown and other measures to contain these new variants.
As epidemiologists and politicians worldwide have so clearly declared, ‘no-one is safe until everyone is safe’. The current supply shortages and associated vaccine nationalism do not bode well either for the number of shots needed worldwide or for international cooperation, at least in the short-medium term. So, we should perhaps expect delays.
The UK and USA are making impressive progress with mass vaccination; Europe is several weeks behind the UK; and many less developed countries are probably at the end of a long queue, which, sadly, may be one to two years away from widespread vaccination.
A third wave lockdown which, if it were to happen, would likely occur in mid-late autumn in the UK, as returning travellers bring new variants home with them. This would add salt to the already gaping wounds of the inbound tourism industry. The inability to trade in the otherwise normally busy third quarter, before the traditionally fallow winter season, would propel many more businesses to a financial cliff edge.
More fingers crossed this doesn’t happen, and vaccine supply is ramped up and rolled out faster around the world than currently looks likely.
How Quickly Will the Economy Recover?
On a positive note, the WTTC predicts that, if the global vaccine rollout were to continue at pace and travel restrictions were to be relaxed before the summer season, the 62 million jobs lost globally in 2020 could return by 2022. Even if that seems an ambitious timescale in light of current vaccination progress and infection rates, the implication that tourism-related jobs can recover within a one to two-year timeframe, is encouraging.
But perhaps the more important question is ‘How will the economy recover?’, rather than ‘When will it recover?’
We are likely to face a two-speed economy in the UK after the end of the Job Retention Scheme: a greater divergence than before between the ‘haves’ and the ‘have-nots’. Inequalities will be even more polarised as many return to work, but others are laid off as businesses are unable to reopen or reduce their staff.
The hospitality industry has been one of the hardest hit during the pandemic. It has become illegal to indulge in the two things that are critical to the tourism and hospitality sector: travel, and spending time with others. It’s as if you sheared the wings of airplanes and still expected them to fly. Nothing could be more detrimental to the tourism industry than restricting travel. You can’t take delivery of a holiday via Amazon.
So, recovery will depend on those in work, and the retired, getting out and spending their money to stimulate economic activity in the tourism sector, especially in their own country. But the need to fund an increase in unemployment and to begin paying back the debt arising from the UK’s biggest ever peacetime borrowing, is likely eventually to involve tax increases, which will inevitably reduce discretionary spending on items such as travel and eating out.
Nevertheless, travel is likely to remain one of the first priorities for discretionary spending, for those who can still afford it. So, the onus will be on those with savings, in work, and retired, to drive the resurgence of the visitor economy.
And, hopefully, more people will choose to spend more time doing so in their own country, having got a taste for it while they’ve been unable to travel out of it.
CONCLUSION
Roadmap to Recovery
We may still be far from the sunlit uplands of full recovery. But, with the clouds of the pandemic beginning to clear, we can start to see the road that leads towards that horizon.
There are still likely to be potholes along the road, as we face perhaps a resurgence of infection, new variants, and a consequent, temporary reimposition of constraints on our leisure activities. But the science is on our side, the tourism industry knows what to do, and the consumer appetite is there to be unleashed whenever it is safe and permissible to travel.
As well as stimulating travel as soon as feasible, there are two major considerations we all need to strive towards, which have been emphasised by wise heads around the world:
- We will have to learn to live with this virus.
- We will need to work hard to make the whole world safe because, until then, none of us are safe.
Recovery may take time. But vaccines, political will, global cooperation, human ingenuity, and a worldwide love of travel, are the ingredients that should, together, inspire confidence and, eventually, help tourism bounce back. There is no reverse gear to this recovery. It may just take a year or so to reach top gear. In the meantime, there is hope for the medium-long-term.
And we can look forward to hugs and home-based holidays in the short-medium-term.
......………….Here’s to hitting the road again, and happy hugging.
(March 2021)